"Seeing the Bigger Picture: How the Health Research Board Uses Open Research Monitor Ireland"

Patricia Clarke is a Programme Manager at the Health Research Board (HRB), Ireland's national funder for health research. She is responsible for coordinating HRB's open science agenda and its open access policy, which was revised and came into effect on 1 January 2025.

The Health Research Board (HRB) is Ireland's national funder for health research, operating at the intersection of science, policy, and public benefit. For Patricia Clarke, HRB Programme Manager, the question of open access has never been a simple compliance checkbox. It is a system-level challenge that requires the right data, the right comparators, and the right infrastructure to manage.

Open Research Monitor Ireland (ORMI), developed by IReL in partnership with OpenAIRE, is one of the tools that can support this work. Patricia spoke with the OpenAIRE Monitor team about how HRB has engaged with the platform, where it provides useful insights and what she would like to see from it in the future.

Can you tell us about your role and how open access fits into your work?

Open access is one part of my role in the HRB. I'm responsible for coordinating the open science agenda at HRB and for our open access policy, which we revised and brought into effect on 1 January 2025. That involved looking at how we could become Plan S compliant, how we fund open access in our research budgets, how we facilitate open access for publications beyond the term of a grant, and how to make it work for all researchers within our health research community.

We set up an internal open science governance group that brings together people from strategy, finance, research and the library, because different parts of the organisation were engaging with open access separately. The goal is to look at it as a whole rather than in isolated parts. We've been working on open access since 2014, and we do take transparency and openness seriously. Alongside our open access policy, we provide our Funder open publication platform, HRB Open Research, we have a research data management policy, we support ORCID integration, and we use Researchfish for monitoring and evaluation. The broader aim is making sure the research we fund is accessible, useful, and used.

How did HRB first come to use Monitor, and did you trust what you were seeing?

We were automatically included in the initial rollout of the Irish Monitor in 2024. Like many organisations, we were still learning how it might fit alongside existing systems and reporting processes, and we were keen to understand the insights it could provide and how it might support our open access monitoring activities.

On trust, because the Monitor was developed as a national infrastructure through IReL and links into OpenAIRE, we approached it with a level of confidence. We're familiar with OpenAIRE through its role in supporting open science and research information infrastructures across Europe, particularly for Horizon Europe. We were interested in seeing what additional insights the Monitor could offer us on issues such as data quality, metadata completeness and we were keen to compare with our existing HRB systems. It helped us understand what each system does well.

"It's valuable that this system gives a national picture. It's system level, it allows us to compare across organisations, and to look at trends over time in a straightforward way."

What do you find most valuable in Monitor's indicators?

For me, one of the most useful aspects is the breakdown of open access into different routes and categories rather than presenting it as a simple yes-or-no measure. Being able to see distinctions between different types of open access, licensing approaches and publication routes provides a very granular level of detail.

One indicator I'm hoping to understand better is immediacy, whether outputs are openly available at the point of publication or become available later following an embargo. Under our open access policy understanding whether funded outputs are achieving immediate open access is important, but monitoring this consistently is challenging.

We've recently introduced a dedicated budget code for article processing charges (APCs) within HRB systems to improve our understanding of expenditure in this area. Looking at our APC spending is an area where further exploration of the Monitor's capabilities could be useful.

Has Monitor changed the decisions you're able to make?

One main value of Monitor is that it provides a common set of indicators that can be viewed across multiple funders and organisations. That kind of benchmarking is not always easy to obtain from individual internal systems.

I deliberately aligned HRB's open access policy as closely as possible with other Irish funders, particularly Research Ireland. Researchers within Irish universities are often dealing with multiple funders, and I wanted to avoid having to report against two variant policies seeking to achieve the same outcome if we could avoid it. Having access to comparable information across funders using common metrics can help support that kind of coordination and provides useful context when reviewing progress at a national level.

It's also prompting us to think about compliance monitoring differently. Rather than focusing solely on individual researchers, we're interested in understanding patterns at organisation level, and working with Research Offices and libraries to address issues systematically. Monitor can contribute to that broader perspective alongside the information we gather through our own processes.

"We want to monitor compliance on our policy at an institutional level. Rather than going back to individual researchers, developing open access practices is something that the research organisations could lead on."

How do you bring Monitor data into meetings or reports?

Mostly screenshots, so far. I've used Monitor visuals when reporting on our involvement in the pilot, and when discussing HRB's position within the wider national context. We're gradually moving towards more dashboard-based approaches.

During the interview, the Monitor team shared two features Patricia hadn't been aware of: an embed button on each graph that allows any indicator to be placed directly onto a website or interactive report, updating automatically when the data updates; and the ability to download the underlying data per graph as a CSV or Excel file. Both opened new possibilities for how Monitor data could feature in HRB's internal reporting.

"The embedded functionality would be useful. I must have a look at that more closely."

Has there been a moment where you realised Monitor was more than just an OA tool?

I think Monitor has the potential to contribute to wider discussions about Ireland's research landscape. Publications are only one part of the picture. Having national-level information that can support benchmarking, trend analysis and policy discussions is valuable.

As Ireland considered progress against national open research objectives and the implementation of the NORF framework, tools that bring together information from different sources may have an increasingly important role. Whether Monitor develops into a broader strategic resource will depend on continued engagement, data quality and its ability to meet user needs... it's definitely providing more.

The metadata and persistent identifier layer are particularly interesting because they have applications beyond simple publication tracking. There is potential there, although it is still developing.

"It would be good to use the full potential of the Monitor."

What would you tell a colleague who hasn't used Monitor yet, and what would you like to see from it?

I'd describe it as a useful national infrastructure for system-level insight, benchmarking and tracking over time. But I wouldn't necessarily expect people to discover its value on their own. Most organisations are already busy managing many different systems and reporting requirements. An effective approach may be a facilitated demonstration, getting the Monitor team in to walk through what the platform does, where it adds value, and why it matters. I'd be happy to set that up at HRB.

On what's missing: I'd be interested in functionality that allows organisations to create tailored reports, bringing together selected indicators into a single output. The existing embedding and download features are helpful, but a more structured reporting layer with narrative summaries alongside visualisations would make it easier to integrate Monitor outputs into internal briefings and presentations.

"It would be a shame to have it there and not use it."

In Closing

For Patricia, the Monitor is a new piece of national research infrastructure that is helping to provide a broader view on open access towards informing discussions about the evolving landscape. Its value will continue to grow as more organisations engage with it and more capabilities are added.

Recent work on project-level integration and text mining has already improved how HRB-funded outputs are linked and discovered in OpenAIRE Explore, and the kind of structured, exportable reporting layer she'd like to see next is something the Monitor team is actively considering for future development, part of an ongoing effort to make the platform more useful with every release.

format_quote

We want to monitor compliance on our policy at an institutional level. Rather than going back to individual researchers, developing open access practices is something that the research organisations could lead on.

About
Patricia Clarke
Patricia Clarke
Programme Manager, Health Research Board
Funder
Interview date
May 2026
Indicator granularityCross-funder comparisonPolicy alignmentCompliance tracking
Share your story

Have a story to tell?

We'd love to feature your experience. Get in touch and we'll take it from there.

Contact us